dddd
PublishedDecember 22, 2016

Smartphone Patent Wars, a Poem

‘Twas the week before Christmas,
And all through the news,
The smartphone patent wars
Were giving us the blues.

Just when we thought
Apple-Samsung was done,
Nokia decided
To rejoin the fun.

Nokia sued Apple,
For their deal had expired,
New patents, new charges,
New lawyers were hired.

Apple, in turn,
Would now claim antitrust
Violations. It seems that
The peace was a bust.

Nokia, said Apple,
Was hiring trolls.
To exploit their patents,
They’d licensed their souls.

In Marshall of Texas,
Nokia filed a new case,
Ironically claiming,
“We’re not trolls. You’re off base.”

“You used our inventions,
You must pay us for that.”
But Santa was listening,
And he took off his hat.

He wiped his broad brow,
As his eyes formed a tear,
“It’s Christmas,” he said.
“Can’t they wait ‘til next year?”

“This month is reserved
For good will towards men.
Besides, we’re exhausted.
I mean, smartphones again?”

Yup, that’s right. The smartphone patent wars have reignited. Happy Holidays!

 

Matt Levy

Previously, Matt was patent counsel at the Computer & Communications Industry Association

More Posts

Sen. Coons, RESTORE This Bill to the Shelf

On Tuesday, Sen. Chris Coons introduced the RESTORE Act.  This bill tries to overturn the Supreme Court’s eBay v. MercExchange decision.  Justice Thomas, writing for a unanimous court in e...

RESTORE Act Leaves District Courts Vulnerable to NPE Abuse

As I discussed in Patent Progress back in July, the RESTORE Act, introduced in July by Senators Chris Coons and Tom Cotton, would bring back automatic injunctions to U.S. district courts. RESTORE is ...

Failed Disclosure Request Shows the Lingering Threat of Undisclosed Litigation Finance

In August, Delaware Chief District Judge Colm Connolly denied Apple’s request for access to details on the litigation funding arrangement between the Finnish company MPH Technologies, which is suing...

American Technology Manufacturers Renew Fight Against Fintiv

In a renewed effort to challenge the so-called NHK-Fintiv rule, earlier this month Apple, Cisco, Google, and Intel asked the Federal Circuit to strike down the widely-criticized Fintiv doctrine for be...

Subscribe to Patent Progress

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.