PublishedMay 14, 2013

The Economy Doesn’t Suffer If a Troll Patent Is Infringed, But an Angel Does Get Its Wings

Last week at a panel discussion, a representative from Intellectual Ventures made a complaint. Why, this person asked, don’t people take into account the negative effect of patent infringement on the economy?

This being a blog in the public interest, we are more than happy to help out. We’ll address the question that’s most relevant for IV, namely, what’s the negative effect on the economy of infringing patents owned by PAEs?

SPOILER ALERT: there is none.

Why is that? It’s because even though a PAE might have less money than it otherwise wants to have, the economy loses nothing.

Consider an example. Suppose I’m in line to buy a lottery ticket. The guy in front of me, Bob, has his numbers picked randomly, as do I. I, as I always do, lose. But Bob wins a multimillion dollar prize. If only I’d cut in front of him!

What is the effect on the economy? Nothing. I am worse off in the sense that I think those should be my millions, but the economy still gets the benefit. The economy doesn’t care who wins the lottery. The same money is out there in circulation.

Similarly, just because some PAE thinks it should be entitled to be paid off for having purchased someone else’s patent, the economy is no worse off.

Put another way, your disappointment in your get-rich quick scheme failing is not a drag on the economy.

Businesses wasting millions defending against lawsuits by patent trolls, however, is.

Matt Levy

Previously, Matt was patent counsel at the Computer & Communications Industry Association

More Posts

Federal Circuit Temporarily Pauses Judge Connolly’s Disclosure Orders In Delaware

In its order on a mandamus request filed by MAVEXAR-linked entity Nimitz Technologies LLC, the Federal Circuit has temporarily paused Judge Connolly's order that entities in his court disclose details...

With frivolous NPE patent suits clogging courts, counsel’s diligence and ethics suffer

U.S. patent litigation is big business. Billion-dollar judgments, readily available litigation financing, and favorable venues and lax filing standards mean between three and four thousand suits are f...

OpenSky’s Sanction and Continued VLSI Patent Review are Both Warranted

Over the past few weeks there have been major developments in the much-discussed dispute related to patents held by the non-practicing entity VLSI Technology. On Patent Progress we have previously wri...

Subscribe to Patent Progress

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.